I'm a huge Misfits fan, but I would agree that it's way over produced. And try as he might, Jerry Only is not a lead vocalist. The songs sound much better when they play them live though, so I really think the production makes the vocals sound worse than they really are. Doesn't compare to the Danzig albums, or the Michale Graves albums, but I'd listen to most of it again. Where Do They Go is the only song I would call terrible. Dez Cadena (Black Flag) sings lead vocals on Jack the Ripper and Death Ray, which is cool if you're a Black Flag fan. If you're going to judge it by one song, I'd say give either Sleepwalkin', Unexplained, or Jack the Ripper a try.
Have good mosh pitting.